Saturday, September 29, 2018
Le Prophete from France
Conductor: Claus Peter Flor
Director: Alfonso Caiani
Jean de Leyde, tenor, John Osborn
Fidès, Jean's mother, mezzo-soprano, Kate Aldrich
Berthe, Jean's bride, soprano, Sofia Fomina
Jonas, an Anabaptist, tenor, Mikeldi Atxalandabase
Mathisen, an Anabaptist, bass or baritone, Thomas Dear
Zacharie, an Anabaptist, bass, Dimitry Ivashchenko
Oberthal, a feudal count, bass, Leonardo Estevez
Meyerbeer's Le Prophete (1849) came to me from Toulouse by way of Culture Box. My only live experience of Meyerbeer was L'Africaine at the San Francisco Opera. I begin to think Meyerbeer is neglected, perhaps not in France but certainly here. Perhaps Yannick will change this.
Giocomo Mayerbeer was a truly international composer as very few are. He was born in Berlin of rich Jewish parents, studied and composed extensively in Italy in the time of Rossini, and then established himself in Paris and Berlin. We know him primarily for his French operas. However, Robert le Diable was written for Berlin. It is hard to grasp that such a prominent composer is virtually unknown to me. As would be expected, his works are orchestrated in the German style, emphasize chorus like a French opera and don't particularly follow the Italian ideal of bel canto. I think I should delve further before making any decisions about him. He is the main proponent of Grand Opera, a style that includes:
(a) obligatory spectacular scenes,
(b) death, not happy endings, in librettos by Scribe, (including this one),
(c) potpourri overture,
(d) extended ornate arias, though less ornate than bel canto,
(e) chorus and ballet, and
(f) a new heavier type of dramatic tenor as the featured hero.
Two of his most famous operas concern European religious minorities, here the Anabaptists. They are at war with the main population. We in America have had a great political civil war, but until the recent events have never experienced religious wars. Many may dislike people from other religions, but the phenomenon of taking up arms against them has not happened. We love our religious freedom.
You have to enjoy John Osborn to like this performance. There is a lovely duet between Aldrich and Fomina. Two hours in we have kitschy almost naked ladies. People are singing in Latin. There is a huge role in this opera for mezzo, Fidès, originally sung by Pauline Viardot. I like Kate Aldrich but imagine Viardot must have been heavier. I think this whole scene is supposed to be in a church.
Jean makes a big entrance in a crown and white robe. He says he's the son of god and Fidès calls out "my son." He says "who is this woman?" Someone says she blasphemes. Women surround her. She sees that things will go bad for him if he admits she's her son. He's supposed to be god's son. So then the coronation goes on.
This music is interesting and often quite beautiful. It follows in the footsteps of Gluck who was very influential in France. There is no discernible recitative, but there are arias. The orchestration is like Berlioz to my ears. For my ears it's more musically sophisticated than bel canto. There is only occasional ornamentation with nothing like the extended coloratura found in the bel canto operas of the era. However, at the beginning of Act V there is an enormous, florid aria for Fidès. Viardot may have insisted. The music is pleasing, but the plots are outside our knowledge. It is not, I think, a coincidence that I have only seen L'Africaine which is about Vasco da Gama, someone we learned about in school. I predict Le Prophete will never be popular here.
The biggest problem with this performance is that the voices need to be heavier. Here toward the end is an incredible trio. All in all I enjoyed it.