Fiordiligi: Malin Hartelius, Dorabella: Marie-Claude Chappuis, Despina: Martina Janková, Ferrando: Martin Mitterrutzner, Guglielmo: Luca Pisaroni, Don Alfonso: Gerald Finley,
Perhaps it was too soon for me to see another Cosi fan tutte. I think if you get enough opera lovers together, everything will find someone to dislikes it. We used to say "Gesmacksache!"
So I will just tell the things I liked. The Despina of Martina Jankova was fresh and entertaining. I don't know why I never noticed this before, but Don Alfonso only wins because he cheats by persuading Despina to do all the work for him.
The set was a giant spa with a bath in the center and palm trees all around. In the second act the bath is covered and the palms move outside. This was a very conservative production, but still someone wanted to know "Why?"
Both of our baritones, Luca Pisaroni as Guglielmo and Gerald Finley as Don Alfonso, were excellent. Christoph Eschenbach conducted some outstanding ensembles, the key to a successful Cosi.
Our audience was very pleased, with sustained rhythmic clapping that went on for a long time.
The disguises were lame, as usual. This time Ferrando gets Fiordiligi and Guglielmo rejects Dorabella, the consolation prize. Don Alfonzo drinks poison and dies. There's a lot to be explained here. How about Fiordiligi goes to Ferrando and Guglielmo stabs him? Wouldn't that make more sense?
I bought a program for Cosi and it lists the casts of every performance of Cosi at the Salzburg Festival. It makes for some fascinating reading.