Monday, December 05, 2011
Ranking Baroque Opera Performances
Giulio Cesare in Egitto at the Zurich Opera on 4/9/2005.
Semele at the City Opera on 9/14/2006.
Il Trionfo del Tempo e del Disinganno at the Zurich Opera on 1/19/2007.
Semele at the Zurich Opera on 2/15/2007.
Ariodante at the San Francisco Opera on 6/25/2008.
Rinaldo at the Zurich Opera on 7/3/2008.
Orlando at the Sacramento Opera on 11/20/2010.
Griselda at the Santa Fe Opera on 8/6/2011.
Dido and Aeneas at Cal Performances on 9/19/2011.
Xerxes at the San Francisco Opera on 11/17/2011.
Rodelinda in HD from the Metropolitan Opera on 12/3/2011.
Giulio Cesare in Egitto from Salzburg on 5/27/2012.
Partenope at the San Francisco Opera on 10/16/2014.
Much as I love Dido and Aeneas, I have to disqualify it on grounds that it was staged as a ballet. This leaves a very nice set of 10 operas (now expanded to 12.)
Placed at the bottom must come (11) Griselda, Vivaldi's only entry, because I absolutely hated both the opera and the staging, and (12) Orlando, because the overall quality of the entire performance was inferior to the others.
Next higher in the rankings come the two productions from the San Francisco Opera which are saved solely by the presence of the magnificent Susan Graham. The productions were unimaginative, and Xerxes is just not that great an opera. So that's (9) Ariodante and (10) Xerxes.
All eight of the remaining performances are worthy.
Is the opera any good? Giulio Cesare is a Baroque opera that has actually stayed in the repertoire since the 1920's and is Handel's most popular opera. Semele and Il Trionfo are not operas at all. Rinaldo includes the wonderful villainess Armida to keep things exciting. Rodelinda is simply sweet beyond belief, a surprisingly sentimental plot for Baroque opera. Ranked for libretto from first to last: Giulio, Rodelinda, Semele, Partenope, Rinaldo, Trionfo. Ranked for music: Giulio, Il Trionfo, Semele, Rodelinda, Partenope, Rinaldo. You may feel free to rearrange this one.
Tops for creativity in staging must come Semele at the City Opera, Rodelinda in New York and Il Trionfo in Zurich. A special award for making a Theatrical Silk Purse out of Sow's Ear of completely static oratorio must go to Il Trionfo. Turning the oratorio Semele into an opera about American icons was shocking but fascinatingly believable. It would have been nice to see this preserved on video. Now from 2014 I would place Partenope at the top. It was simply incredible.
A special award for making the movements of the actors during the performance of da capo arias seem completely natural must go to Rodelinda. I also enjoyed the Eurotrash transformation of Rinaldo into modern corporate rivalry.
Ranked for staging: Partenope, Rodelinda, Il Trionfo, City Semele, Rinaldo, Giulio Salzburg, Zurich Semele, Giulio Zurich.
And how is the singing? Two of these performances are ranked basically because they include the ever astounding Cecilia Bartoli. Would I have been happy to see Giulio Cesare without Cecilia? And Semele in Zurich simply belonged to her.
The presence of Anna Bonitatibus also raises Il Trionfo and Giulio Cesare. The Zurich singing ensemble is simply incredible. Malin Hartelius is marvelous in Il Trionfo and Rinaldo, and I love Liliana Nikiteanu in Semele and Rinaldo. If I missed anyone, apologies.
The most emotional countertenor award has to go to Andreas Scholl for Rodelinda.
Ranked for singing: Giulio both, Rodelinda, Il Trionfo, Griselda, Partenope, Zurich Semele, Rinaldo, City Semele.
Ranked for acting: Rodelinda, Giulio, Partenope, Zurich Semele, City Semele, Rinaldo, Il Trionfo,
Je ne sais qua points go to Rodelinda and both versions of Semele. I give 3 of these to Partenope, a truly astounding staging.
So here's what I ended up with, based on a numeric scoring system:
(1) Rodelinda. Everything was simply perfect.
(2) Giulio Cesare, both versions.
(4) Semele in Zurich. Cecilia at her funniest.
(5) Semele at City.
(6) Il Trionfo del Tempo e del Disinganno. This was some of the most spectacular singing I've ever heard, but lost on other issues.
(7) Rinaldo. This ended up at the bottom because of the competition.
It is clear to me that I thoroughly enjoyed all six of these, and could rearrange this ranking a dozen different ways. Biggest surprise from the numeric scoring system: Griselda moved ahead of Ariodante and Xerxes.
I think Baroque opera, particularly Handel opera, requires an enthusiasm for singing to overcome its limitations. Probably the greatest limitation is the presence of countertenors. A lot of people just don't like them. Notable in my list is that Trionfo and Rinaldo, both from Zurich, had no countertenors.