Showing posts with label Top 20. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Top 20. Show all posts

Monday, June 10, 2019

Whitsun 2020 - Cancelled

Pauline Viardot-Garcia

Cecilia Bartoli's Whitsun Festival at Salzburg in 2020 will be an homage to Pauline Viardot-Garcia (1821 – 1910), the sister of Maria Malibran.  Viardot's voice did not precisely mesh with Cecilia's, which explains why she has not featured her before.

The Pfingstfest as curated by La Bartoli usually features a fully staged opera starring herself that is presented twice.  Next year it will be Donizetti's Don Pasquale sung in a version ornamented for Viardot and directed by Moshe Leiser and Patrice Caurier.  This should be fun.

Berlioz created an arrangement of Gluck's Orphée et Eurydice for Pauline which she sang over 150 times.  This will be the second opera and will not feature Cecilia.  I once reviewed this arrangement from a DVD here.

The remainder of the festival generally involves concerts.  One will feature the great choral works the Fauré Requiem and the Brahms Alto Rhapsody, both works which I love very much.  There will be a staged song matinee with songs by Viardot and starring mezzo-soprano Vivica Genaux.

The festival will end with a gala concert designed as an homage to the entire Garcia family:  Cecilia Bartoli as Maria Malibran, Varduhi Abrahamyan as Pauline Viardot, and Javier Camarena as Manuel García.  There is much to love.  I haven't been traveling for health reasons, but perhaps I should at least consider this.  The dates are May 29 - June 1.

P.S. Cecilia Bartoli has extended her Whitsun Festival contract to 2026.

Thursday, May 31, 2018

Jonas Kaufmann: "I was sexually harassed"

From Der Tagesspiegel we have:

Jonas Kaufmann: „Ich wurde sexuell belästigt“

Jonas Kaufmann berichtet über sexuelle Nötigung. Am Anfang seiner Karriere wurde ihm ein Konzert angeboten - Bedingung: eine Gegenleistung. 
Jonas Kaufmann reports sexual coercion. At the beginning of his career he was offered a concert - condition: a consideration.

Tenor Jonas Kaufmann ist zu Beginn seiner Karriere sexuell belästigt worden. Auch Männer seien davor nicht gefeit, sagte der 48-Jährige der Mailänder Tageszeitung „Corriere della Sera“ mit Blick auf die MeToo-Debatte. „Ich kenne die Situation gut, als ich jung war, ist es mir auch passiert. Ich stand am Anfang meiner Karriere, als mir ein Manager ein Konzert anbot, eine fantastische Gelegenheit. 
Tenor Jonas Kaufmann was sexually harassed at the beginning of his career. "Even men are not immune to it," said the 48-year-old in the Milanese newspaper Corriere della Sera with a view to the MeToo debate. "I know the situation well, when I was young, it happened to me too. At the beginning of my career, when a manager offered me a concert, it was a fantastic opportunity.

Im Gegenzug hätte ich aber mit ihm in die Sauna gehen müssen. Das war ein sehr expliziter Tausch. Ich hatte Angst und habe Nein gesagt.“ Sexuelle Erpressung sei „grauenhaft“, so Kaufmann. „Man muss den Mut haben, sie aufzudecken.“ Der Klassikstar beklagte aber auch, dass in den USA ein Mann nicht mehr allein mit einer Frau in einem Raum sein könne, ohne dass eine Kamera laufe. „Die Gefahr, der Belästigung beschuldigt zu werden, ist zu groß.“ dpa 
"In return, I would have had to go to the sauna with him. That was a very explicit exchange. I was scared and said no."  Sexual blackmail was "horrible," according to Kaufmann. "You have to have the courage to uncover them."  But the classic star also complained that in the US, a man can no longer be alone with a woman in a room without a camera running. "The danger of being accused of harassment is too great."

The machine translated this just fine.  I adjusted the punctuation.

Wednesday, January 01, 2014

Anja Harteros

2013 for me was the year of Anja Harteros. Before that I posted nothing about her. When I went to Munich to see Lohengrin in 2009, I remember the soprano was not Anja. Watching the film of Lohengrin may have been my first experience of her.

She is a German of Greek extraction. My impression of her from the interview I translated of Jonas and her together is that she is possibly funny.  Meaning humorous and cheerful. You might possibly believe it of her that she would deliberately play off her long curly-haired resemblance to Cecilia Bartoli at the Cardiff Singer of the World competition, which she won.


She will never be the rock star celebrity that Anna Netrebko is, but her growth into a Verdi singer has been completely organic.  Her natural lyric soprano voice expands into dramatic intensity with almost no discernible change in color or production.  The voice never disintegrates into distortion which so often happens with Verdi.  She never seems to be trying to sound suitable for Verdi--she just is.  She opens her throat and out it comes.  Your heart does not hesitate to soar with her.  I only recall Eileen Farrell who could do this equally well.

The Italians, of course, would not approve.  Jonas and Anja are attempting to convince us that Verdi was a German, too.  The Italians will not be convinced.  They both seem to feel with the music without having any intuitive inclination to scoop.  For me if the drama of the phrase carries seamlessly, I simply don't notice.  My heart wants only to stay in the phrase to the end.

The roles I have heard are Elsa, Leonora (Trovatore), Leonora (Forza), and Elisabetta, all with Jonas Kaufmann.  She's doing Tosca and Simon Boccanegra later this year.  It's interesting to me that I accept her more as a Verdi singer than as a Strauss singer.  She seems most effective in the large gestures, the sweeping landscapes.  I cannot help wondering if she saw what a giant leap this Verdi year would be in her career.  If it was planned, it was a master stroke.  Congratulations.

I don't get the impression that New York is seeking her out.  They are busy promoting Sondra.  I feel very pleased to have someone new to feel enthusiastic about.

On to 2014.  The search for great new singers never ends.

Wednesday, October 02, 2013

Sexiest Conductors

While out of town for Thanksgiving, it has been suggested to me to conduct a sexiest conductors contest. These are the proposed contestants:


Joana Carneiro is a new entry for sexiest conductor.  She is currently the conductor of the Berkeley Symphony.  Conductors have all the fun.


Russian Valery Gergiev is general director and artistic director of the Mariinsky Theatre in Saint Petersburg and principal conductor of the London Symphony Orchestra.

Finn Esa-Pekka Salonen is currently Principal Conductor and Artistic Advisor of the Philharmonia Orchestra in London.

Venezuelan Gustavo Dudamel is currently the principal conductor of the Gothenburg Symphony in Gothenburg, Sweden, and music director of the Los Angeles Philharmonic.

Italian Nicola Luisotti is music director of San Francisco Opera since September 2009 and principal guest conductor of the Tokyo Symphony Orchestra.

American Marin Alsop is music director of the Baltimore Symphony Orchestra.

American Michael Tilson Thomas is currently music director of the San Francisco Symphony.

Italian Riccardo Muti is music director of the Chicago Symphony Orchestra. He apparently has backed out of directing the Rome Opera.

American Kent Nagano is music director of the Orchestre Symphonique de Montréal and the Bavarian State Opera.  After 30 years, he has finally given up the Berkeley Symphony.

Englishman Sir Simon Rattle is principal conductor of the Berlin Philharmonic.

German Christian Thielemann was in October 2009 appointed the chief conductor of the Staatskapelle Dresden, effective with the 2012-2013 season. He is also effectively the music director of the Bayreuth Festival.

Since people in Europe have been ignoring the Americans, I have been careful to name a few, along with conductors working mainly in America.  Have I omitted your favorite?

Lucy wants to nominate Laurence Equilbey, conductor of Chœur de Chambre Accentus, a small group that works regularly with the Limoges Baroque Ensemble.  I wanted a picture that looks more like she is conducting, to go with the rest.


Emmanuelle Haïm also belongs in this list.


This is Pablo Heras-Casado who started out in early music.

This is fun.

Friday, May 03, 2013

Sexy Pictures

I'm always on the lookout for new sexy pictures of opera singers.  Here are a few.


This one is called René Pape Easy Rider.  I'm not too young to remember this movie.


This is Noah Stewart in The Pearl Fishers. He works out.


Every picture of Vittorio Grigolo is sexy.


The same could be said of Dmitri Hvorostovsky.  This picture is by Pavel Antonov.


And I'm not exactly sure why I find this picture of  Piotr Beczala sexy.  It's sort of the Thin Man syndrome.  Or just exactly why is Die Fledermaus so sexy?

Clearly I need a new sexy picture of Jonas.  The girls don't seem to be keeping up.

I use a lot of pictures from around the internet uncredited, but many of them are in costume.  I always assume these are freely available as publicity.

Saturday, February 25, 2012

100 most frequently performed operas

I have discovered a more legitimate source for the 100 most frequently performed operas. It comes from the statistics page of a website called Operabase. They even say how the statistics are compiled: Over the 5 seasons, 2005/06 to 2009/10.

Key:   rank, country, (rank for country) composer (rank for composer) opera (performance count)

1at (#1)Mozart (#1)Die Zauberflöte (451) 
2it (#1)Verdi (#1)La traviata (447)
3fr (#1)Bizet (#1)Carmen (424) 
4it (#2)Puccini (#1)La bohème (420) 
5at (#2)Mozart (#2)Le nozze di Figaro (399) 
6it (#3)Puccini (#2)Tosca (379) 
7at (#3)Mozart (#3)Don Giovanni (360)
8it (#4)Puccini (#3)Madama Butterfly (349)
9it (#5)Rossini (#1)Il barbiere di Siviglia (327) 
10it (#6)Verdi (#2)Rigoletto (314) 
11at (#4)Mozart (#4)Così fan tutte (282) 
12it (#7)Donizetti (#1)L'elisir d'amore (218) 
13it (#8)Verdi (#3)Aida (215) 
14de (#1)Humperdinck (#1)Hänsel und Gretel (212) 
15it (#9)Puccini (#4)Turandot (206)
16at (#5)Strauss,J (#1)Die Fledermaus (200) 
17it (#10)Verdi (#4)Nabucco (183) 
18ru (#1)Tchaikovsky (#1)Eugene Onegin (175) 
19it (#11)Donizetti (#2)Lucia di Lammermoor (170) 
20it (#12)Leoncavallo (#1)Pagliacci (159) 
21at (#6)Mozart (#5)Die Entführung (157)
22hu (#1)Lehár (#1)Die lustige Witwe (149)
23it (#13)Verdi (#5)Il trovatore (147) 
24it (#14)Verdi (#6)Falstaff (144) 
25de (#2)Wagner,R (#1)Der fliegende Holländer (137)
26it (#15)Verdi (#7)Un ballo in maschera (136)
27it (#16)Mascagni (#1)Cavalleria rusticana (131) 
28it (#17)Verdi (#8)Otello (129) 
29it (#18)Rossini (#2)La cenerentola (124) 
30fr (#2)Offenbach (#1)Les contes d'Hoffmann (123) 
31it (#19)Verdi (#9)Macbeth (123) 
32de (#3)Strauss,R (#1)Salome (121) 
33de (#4)Wagner,R (#2)Das Rheingold (115) 
34de (#5)Beethoven (#1)Fidelio (112) 
35fr (#3)Gounod (#1)Faust (111) 
36de (#6)Wagner,R (#3)Die Walküre (110)
37de (#7)Strauss,R (#2)Der Rosenkavalier (104) 
38it (#20)Bellini (#1)Norma (102)
39de (#8)Wagner,R (#4)Tristan und Isolde (101)
40it (#21)Puccini (#5)Manon Lescaut (99) 
41it (#22)Verdi (#10)Don Carlos (99) 
42it (#23)Donizetti (#3)Don Pasquale (99)
43it (#24)Puccini (#6)Gianni Schicchi (97) 
44de (#9)Weber (#1)Der Freischütz (97) 
45at (#7)Mozart (#6)Idomeneo re di Creta (96)
46de (#10)Strauss,R (#3)Ariadne auf Naxos (93) 
47de (#11)Gluck (#1)Orfeo ed Euridice (90) 
48ru (#2)Tchaikovsky (#2)Pikovaya Dama (89) 
49de (#12)Strauss,R (#4)Elektra (87) 
50de (#13)Wagner,R (#5)Siegfried (86) 
51fr (#4)Massenet (#1)Werther (83)
52at (#8)Mozart (#7)La clemenza di Tito (83) 
53de (#14)Wagner,R (#6)Tannhäuser (82)
54de (#15)Wagner,R (#7)Parsifal (82) 
55it (#25)Rossini (#3)L'italiana in Algeri (82) 
56cz (#1)Dvořák (#1)Rusalka (80) 
57uk (#1)Purcell (#1)Dido and Aeneas (80) 
58ru (#3)Musorgsky (#1)Boris Godunov (76) 
59de (#16)Wagner,R (#8)Götterdämmerung (75) 
60fr (#5)Gounod (#2)Roméo et Juliette (72) 
61cz (#2)Janáček (#1)Jenůfa (71) 
62hu (#2)Kálmán (#1)Die Csárdásfürstin (70) 
63de (#17)Wagner,R (#9)Lohengrin (66)
64it (#26)Verdi (#11)La forza del destino (64) 
65cz (#3)Smetana (#1)Prodaná nevěsta (62) 
66uk (#2)Handel (#1)Giulio Cesare in Egitto (59)
67it (#27)Verdi (#12)Requiem (58) 
68us (#1)Gershwin (#1)Porgy and Bess (56) 
69at (#9)Berg (#1)Wozzeck (56) 
70it (#28)Verdi (#13)Simon Boccanegra (56) 
71fr (#6)Offenbach (#2)Orphée aux enfers (55) 
72it (#29)Monteverdi (#1)L'orfeo (55) 
73ru (#4)Shostakovich (#1)Lady Macbeth of Mtsensk (54) 
74it (#30)Puccini (#7)Suor Angelica (54) 
75hu (#3)Lehár (#2)Das Land des Lächelns (53) 
76it (#31)Donizetti (#4)La fille du régiment (53) 
77de (#18)Wagner,R (#10)Die Meistersinger (50) 
78it (#32)Monteverdi (#2)L'incoronazione di Poppea (50) 
79hu (#4)Kálmán (#2)Gräfin Mariza (49) 
80fr (#7)Bizet (#2)Les pêcheurs de perles (49) 
81uk (#3)Britten (#1)The Turn of the Screw (48) 
82fr (#8)Debussy (#1)Pelléas et Mélisande (48) 
83it (#33)Rossini (#4)Il viaggio a Reims (48) 
84uk (#4)Britten (#2)A Midsummer Night's Dream (47) 
85ru (#5)Stravinsky (#1)The Rake's Progress (47) 
86it (#34)Giordano (#1)Andrea Chénier (45) 
87at (#10)Mozart (#8)La finta giardiniera (45) 
88fr (#9)Poulenc (#1)Dialogues des Carmélites (43) 
89fr (#10)Massenet (#2)Manon (43) 
90at (#11)Strauss,J (#2)Wiener Blut (43) 
91at (#12)Strauss,J (#3)Der Zigeunerbaron (42) 
92it (#35)Bellini (#2)La sonnambula (41) 
93ru (#6)Prokofiev (#1)The Love for Three Oranges (40) 
94fr (#11)Poulenc (#2)La voix humaine (39) 
95at (#13)Benatzky (#1)Im weißen Rößl (39) 
96cz (#4)Janáček (#2)The Cunning Little Vixen (39) 
97it (#36)Puccini (#8)Il Tabarro (37) 
98uk (#5)Britten (#3)Peter Grimes (36) 
99de (#19)Weill (#1)Mahagonny (36) 
100it (#37)Puccini (#9)La fanciulla del West (35)

Obviously a list like this will change over time.  It seems likely that the other list also derives from here, but for a different date range.

Handel is uk and Gluck is Germany.  If Handel is uk, doesn't Gluck have to be Austria?

Sunday, February 05, 2012

Camille Claudel


The 30th anniversary of the Alexander String Quartet in Herbst Theater brought us a very high class concert.

Joyce DiDonato and her accompanist Jake Heggie began the program with Venezia, a cycle of 6 songs in Venetian Dialect by Reynaldo Hahn.  From the stage Joyce told us that these songs were originally performed in Venice in a gondola.  The composer had a small piano put into a gondola and sang them floating around in the lagoon.  You can possibly picture this.  Joyce did not smoke or play the piano herself as Hahn would have done.  This is completely charming and charmingly performed.

This was followed by the Debussy string quartet played by the Alexander String Quartet.  We are so accustomed to this style of music that its effects are no longer remarkable.

Heggie was asked to compose a piece for the anniversary, and he replied that he was an opera composer.  They responded not to worry--they intended to provide a singer, one Joyce DiDonato.  This is a heavenly idea.

Executed like a work from heaven.  The result of this collaboration is Camille Claudel:  Into the Fire (2012), a work for string quartet and mezzo-soprano.  I am pleased to have pulled myself together and made the trip to see it.

This is a remarkable work.  First there is a sculpture--Camille Claudel was a sculptor.


Then there is a poem--"Rodin" in this case--written by Gene Scheer, who is also the librettist of Heggie's Moby-Dick and Picker's An American Tragedy.  So the profession of librettist is not dead after all.  Then there is a song, simultaneously sweet and dramatic to fit images.


"La Valse" "Take me one step closer one step back one step spins one step hovers Take me!"

"La Petite Châtelaine" we all cried.


The story has an unhappy ending.  She began to destroy her sculptures and was subsequently confined to a mental hospital.  The song cycle ends with Claudel as an old woman still in the asylum being visited by an old friend.

The words are lovely.  Heggie is developing into a wonderful composer.  His use of DiDonato's voice is skilled and sensitive.  His writing for string quartet is lyrical and romantic.  It is a very good sign that he calls himself an opera composer.  It was truly a significant occasion.

The encore, "Morgen" by R. Strauss, used everyone in a charming arrangement.

Here is a short blog post from Jake Heggie about this concert.

Monday, January 23, 2012

The Pinnacle of Singing – Jonas Kaufmann

[This is an interview before Jonas' recital at the Musikverein in Vienna, translated from here. Thanks to Emilio for his help in translating "ersungen".]

For several years he is one of the giants of the music scene. In February Jonas Kaufmann is to be a guest at the Musikverein with a Liederabend. In his luggage, the celebrated Verdi and Wagner tenor this time has a rather quiet program.

In the world of opera, there are many clichés. One of them says that only Italian tenors bring sufficient luster for the Italian repertory - maybe even the Spanish-Mexican-Argentine. A second is that in Milan, New York or Paris one could not present to the audience a German as a Latin Lover. A Teuton to succeed internationally as Alfredo (La traviata) and Cavaradossi (Tosca)? Until a few years ago it was unimaginable.

Jonas Kaufmann then entered the international arena. Based in Zurich, where the Munich-born was since the turn of the millennium contracted to sing, he had continuously enriched his audience through singing. 2007 was his solo CD "Romantic Arias" on the market, three more have since followed. There are now a "Fidelio" recording under Claudio Abbado with him, and various DVDs: a "Tosca" from Zurich, a "Werther" in Paris, a "Lohengrin" in Munich and a "Carmen" from London. Even a biography has been published.

That the 42-year-old is an outstanding singer and actor, critics and fans agree. Besides that he also looks good, at least not detrimental to the career. No wonder that a critic of the New York Times recently attested laconically of the singer that he is "currently the hottest tenor in opera". A glance at Kaufmann's diary confirms this: The November and December 2011, he spends at the New York Metropolitan Opera, sings the title role in a new production of "Faust," in January there is a new "Don Carlo" at the Bavarian State Opera in Munich. The advantage of the Munich engagement: Kaufmann can finally sleep in his own bed once again - he lives with his wife, singer Margaret Joswig, and their three children after years in Switzerland, now back on the Isar.  

On your program for the Musikverein are songs by Liszt, Mahler and Richard Strauss - and Henri Duparc (1848-1933), a friend of Camille Saint-Saens' and Ernest Chausson. Three well-known composers, and a relative unknown . What do you like about Duparc?

I think he's a very interesting but underrated composer who unfortunately has only written a few songs. The poems he set to music are, for the most part very expansive, very flowery, very dense atmosphere. And in combination with Duparc's music, these pieces seem so strong that one listening - or singing - believes that landscapes are to see and fragrances to smell. It is a very particular nature of Duparc, that after a few bars of a song, the specific atmosphere can feel almost palpable.  

Do you have among the four, a favorite composer?

Even if these four approach very differently the setting of texts, they are all masterpieces in the genre of song composition. In this respect I do not want to have to choose a favorite composer. For Mahler, it is certainly the increased emotionality that attracts me as a singer in particular. With Liszt the piano virtuoso is of course always in the foreground, so chamber music and songs are often too short. His songs are not nearly as well known as they deserve because of his mastery. In Strauss I can as a tenor "tuck in" more than with other composers, which frankly for me is a lot of fun. But he has also repeatedly phrases, where you can paint with very fine colors. These contrasts feel like a great challenge to me. I also like many Strauss songs for a sense of humor, even self-irony.

You will be accompanied by Helmut Deutsch - you both have a long-standing cooperation. Deutsch has made music with you when you were still a student at the Munich Academy of Music.

Yes, he was my professor in the subject Lied, so we know each other for over twenty years. From the teacher-pupil ratio is then over the years a partnership that I find very harmonious. He's still my mentor in terms of Lieder singing: He has an invaluable wealth of knowledge of singing and song repertoire, from which I have benefitted for years and is basically the foundation of our program design.

They celebrate triumphs on the operatic stage. Why are you still excited by the - perhaps even more difficult - Lied?

Lieder singing to me is the pinnacle of singing. To make Lieder requires a high degree of technical skill and artistic sensibility, which in opera roles is not necessarily the case. As an operatic character one is part of a story; as a song singer, in one evening one tells about twenty different stories. It gives me immense pleasure to show in one evening so many different facets-linguistically, musically, stylistically and dramatically. The singer can work with much more subtle means, not least because the song focuses the attention of the audience to music and text.

On the opera stage, a singer working with a director and a conductor, he has also colleagues as supervisory body. How is this with the Lied? Do you have to fend for yourself?

Yes, as an opera singer, you are part of a larger whole, and you can make even a certain responsibility to the director or the conductor. As Lieder singer is one – together with the pianist - alone responsible. This is a much greater burden, but which, if everything goes well, will be rewarded with greater satisfaction. And what the "Supervisory Body" handles, recordings of rehearsals and concerts are always helpful for me.


Do you remember your debut in Vienna?

Of course! For me this was a great day. A "Fledermaus" at the Volksoper with Heinz Holecek as Frosch in 1997. I sang Alfred and was pretty excited because the Viennese audience is indeed, due to its professional knowledge and its strong interest in things artistic, by us singers equally loved and feared. My debut at the Staatsoper followed nine years later, on June 12, 2006, as Tamino in "Die Zauberflote".

Did you, like many students in Munich, in your study time go occasionally for concerts and operas to Vienna? Do you have memories of the Viennese musical life from the perspective of a spectator?


In my student days, it must have been in 1993, there was a special experience in Vienna, which has not been repeated in this way by luck. From Munich we went with the Bach Choir Fürstenfeldbruck to Vienna to give a performance of "St. John Passion." I should sing the Evangelist and the tenor arias. The whole ensemble took the bus there, and for some reason I took the night train. About an hour before the rehearsal I arrived in the morning at the West Bahnhof, took a taxi and said: "To Peter's Church, please!" Big question mark! The driver did not know Peter's Church, nor did his colleagues. In the days before GPS and cell phone of course we had no other choice than to constantly ask people and to follow some vague references. So we wandered through Vienna for some time, I got as it were a city tour of the most beautiful churches - Votive Church, St. Stephens Dom, etc. - until we finally found the Church of St. Peter. The rehearsal had already started, of course, all were sitting on pins and needles, waiting for me.

As a viewer I especially remember the Viennese New Year's concerts in the Musikverein. To watch television with the family, which belonged to us for New Year's Day just as the fir tree belongs to Christmas. And it was always a special experience: the magnificent hall, the Philharmonic, conductor like Boskovsky, Maazel, Karajan and Abbado, little extras like the gun shots in the Polka "On the Hunt", the beat of the music clapping audience at the "Radetzky March"- all had a very special character, and we children felt instinctively that classical music in Vienna has a stronger meaning than anywhere else in the world.

Does the coming song recital mark your debut at the Musikverein?

No, I have already sung concerts there, before my debut at the Staatsoper. But it's my first Liederabend at the Musikverein, and I am really looking forward to being allowed to sing Lieder in this room with the wonderful acoustic.

Does one dream of it sometimes as a student actually being allowed to sing one day in such historic rooms?

My daydreams as a singing student had relatively little to do with music, with even fewer career (laughs). But if I had asked a fairy godmother at the time in what houses I would like to sing, I would have named three magical places in the world of opera called La Scala, the Met and the Vienna State Opera.

Sunday, September 25, 2011

Is Anna Back?

So maybe you didn't know she was gone.  I have been mad at Anna Netrebko because she refuses to diet off her pregnancy fat.  If you are one of the most beautiful women in the world, you have certain obligations.  Or so I thought.

So today in the New York Times I read that for the last couple of years she has been truly enthusiastic only for home and family.  I think my intuition told me this.  After all, one of the things we most love about Anna is her enthusiasm for performing.  Who but Anna jumps up and down in the final bows, or sticks out her tongue at the camera, or shows off her marvelous joie de vivre.

So (we are trying to start every paragraph with so) the New York Times seems to feel she is regaining her enthusiasm for performing.  She points out that she needs always new things to be singing to maintain her interest.  Anna Bolena is part of this plan.  She is at this moment pretty much the prima donna assoluta.

So she is also doing a recital at Carnegie Hall consisting entirely of Russian songs.  I went to a Netrebko recital years ago with Donald Runnicles accompanying, and concluded that the world did not need Anna Netrebko doing Lieder recitals.  After all we have a lot of perfectly excellent Germans for that.  What the world needed was an artist of Anna's stature singing Russian songs.  If not Anna, then who?  The passage of time has proved me right.  As the years pass, I begin to feel moderately less arrogant, but I was still dead on on this one.

So perhaps the Netrebko is back.

Sunday, June 19, 2011

40 years of James Levine


Long before the Metropolitan Opera broadcast operas in HD into movie theaters there was a TV show called Live from the Met. It was still called this even after it was on tape. Many broadcasts from this series make up the material available on the Met Player. Almost always the first name in the series of names, the one indicating the conductor, is Levine. To us out in the hinterlands it looked like he conducted everything. After all these years James Levine simply is the Metropolitan Opera.

As a comment to a blog post, I was passed a link to a film on PBS about James Levine at the Metropolitan. I see that it is no longer available. I wish I could watch it again. It switched annoyingly around in the subjects, I recall. For me the most interesting parts were the ones where he is shown coaching Placido Domingo.

Levine is a great musician and a great opera conductor, but he is in every aspect of his career and life very much an American. In America we are taught that the music is all on the page. We find the "composer's wishes" by studying the page of music. The music that forms our own heritage is often quite different from the music of classical repertoire.

The part of the music that is not on the page is the part that comes from national tradition. Now Riccardo Muti, a purely Italian conductor, may indeed take it upon himself to purify a score of tradition, as he did in this DVD of Il Trovatore, but his natural Italian soul will prevent him from leaving out the traditional Italian expression.

If Levine has flaws, they lie in the area of making everything from all the different operatic traditions all sound the same.

So we see in the film Placido telling us that when he is learning a new part, he always goes to Jimmy [Levine]. Jimmy's coaching made possible his great achievement in being possibly the greatest Otello of all time. And we see Jimmy helping him work Simon Boccanegra into his voice. And what is the main criticism of Placido Domingo? He makes everything sound the same. I wrote about the Placido Domingo problem here. "He sings a lot of Italian repertoire, but isn't exactly Italian. He has always sung a lot of French opera, but isn't exactly French. Now suddenly in his old age he is a Heldentenor without ever sounding exactly German," I said. Apparently James Levine and Placido Domingo are one. Very interesting.

For me it is always about the music, and I am trying to explore that here.

Levine thinks of himself as the guardian of the past. He is carrying forward to future generations this great art of the past, specifically the past of the Metropolitan Opera.

This includes the heavy romantic sound of the orchestra applied to every era and national style.

This includes the type of loud, heavy voices that are hired for every period and genre. I want to change my mind from what I wrote here: I don't think they're amplified (maybe, maybe not). The Metropolitan Opera both chooses and trains singers to a particular type of brittle penetrating sound. This is felt to be the proper way for an opera singer to sing. The emphasis is very much on sound over style.

One of the results of this is the usual high standard in Verdi performance. Possibly it might even be said that the Metropolitan Opera sets the standard for Verdi performance. It brings power where it is needed in Verdi. There will be articles about Verdi voice, but nothing about Verdi style. People are cast into any role that fits their voice, whether or not they know anything about the style for that genre. Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't.  The Verdi of Maria Callas and Leontyne Price is each particularly wonderful because it succeeds both as voice AND as style.

Each of these opera schools arose in particular places with particular musical cultures. It is only modern life that mixes them all together in the same institutions and blurs the distinctions until these distinctions virtually disappear.

Thus the Metropolitan Opera would make no effort to return Le comte Ory to the more authentic score.

I think this tendency to amalgamate everything into one music that takes place in large institutions like the Met is the true source of the interest in original instruments orchestras. Because they simply cannot achieve the same sound as the traditional opera or symphony orchestra, they look for the music itself in a new place. They don't just sound different; they phrase differently.

The Metropolitan Opera is about standards, and they seem generally pretty high to me. Thus the shock of out of tune horns in Rheingold. It is opera with a generic, particularly American view. Once more we are the melting pot.

I enjoy more the differences. I think once more of the completely astounding Werther at the Paris opera. I had to travel to Paris to know that this was even possible.

There is a certain inevitability to this amalgamation process, especially at the Metropolitan.  In San Francisco our musical directors have come from other places.  Kurt Herbert Adler conducted himself and was a German.  Donald Runnicles is from Great Britain.  Nicola Luisotti, the current musical director, is from Italy.  They bring their national biases with them.

My personal bias is for a more diverse musical scene.  I especially don't like it if all the singers sing the same.  Before HD I was not as exposed to the opera product of the Metropolitan Opera.  The bias toward heavy voices at the Met undoubtedly predates Levine.  Beverly Sills stayed across the plaza.  Elisabeth Schwarzkopf came to San Francisco in 8 different seasons before appearing in New York.  Levine completely identifies with the traditional biases of the Metropolitan and actively works to preserve them.

What would be ideal for me would be quality and diversity together.

Tuesday, May 03, 2011

Jonas Kaufmann Charms New York

This is translated from Frankfurter Neue Presse.


Some artists like the New Yorkers. Some like the audience in the world city very much. And some love them. Jonas Kaufmann is one of this last group. The young German is currently singing at the Metropolitan Opera the role of Siegmund in Richard Wagner's "Walküre" - and is celebrating a wild success.

"The Met is the Eldorado of every singer. All students dream of it - and now it's true," says the 41-year-old. As a child he listened to broadcasts from the legendary opera in New York City on the radio, now the pieces are broadcast worldwide in theaters - with Kaufmann. He is proud to be there: "The Met has always had a special call And it has this rightfully worldwide."

Kaufmann is not unknown at the Met. In 2006 he had his debut in "La Traviata", and last year he helped the newly staged "Tosca" to success that had previously failed with the public. "We simply changed it a little bit and had a lot of fun with it. But we had no idea whether this would reach the audience." It caught on: The second attempt was the premiere we have been waiting for, wrote the New York Times - and Kaufmann had left his footprint.

Now he is the star. While on the posters for "Walküre" is seen the world-class Welsh tenor [uh, bass-baritone] Bryn Terfel, who is known at the Met for 17 years. But the better reviews go to the German: "The audience fell in love with Mr. Kaufmann," wrote The Times after the sweeping premiere of the five-hour piece. "Good-looking and brooding, he embodies all the heroism and self-doubt of the uprooted demigod. His dark, structured and powerful voice has the ideal German color for this music." He was a true tenor, says the New York Times: "He had a great evening."

"Of course it's a great feeling when after the first act everyone jumps up and stands applauding," says Kaufmann. The New York audience was indeed very critical, but also enthusiastic. "Everyone here has the same chance, no matter whether one is a star with a great life of performance, or as a newcomer to the stage. If the performance is right, Americans are generous." Sometimes they are even frenetic. "On the west coast then you have the impression you’re at a pop concert. There are scenes of which we would say in Europe, that does not belong in classical music." [He's talking about Berkeley.  And maybe LA.]

This is Wagner in the city whose music scene is coined/shaped by Jewish artists, supervisors, donors and opera visitors, far from easy. Kurt Masur with the Philharmonic next door in Avery Fisher Hall already had to listen to criticism when he wanted to play Bach's St. Matthew Passion. Then in the middle of April he played “Les Préludes" by Franz Liszt - once the theme song of the Nazi week-show [Wochenschau] - said a Jewish concert visitor, Liszt was ok: "But I would never go to Wagner. Because he was really a Nazi."

"I have often dealt with this issue," says Kaufmann. "But you should be able to separate the work from the composer." About Wagner in New York he has never experienced any animosity. "But you can feel again what it means to be born in Germany and to bear this responsibility. With the generation that lived through the horror, however, I have every understanding."

Kaufmann's appointment calendar is full, even for the 2016/2017 season he already has commitments. Sometimes it is not easy for him and his wife, the mezzo-soprano Margarete Joswig, to have time for the three children. Life at home is sometimes determined by the intra-family democracy: "In the choice of music, we are sometimes overruled," Kaufmann says, sighing, "There will be ever Lady Gaga from the family Radio".

[Sentence fragments and other problems with the text are in the original.]

Monday, February 07, 2011

Cecilia Bartoli Marries


According to Opera Chic the Aargauer Zeitung announced that Cecilia Bartoli and Oliver Widmer have married.  She always said she wouldn't, but you know, never say never.  The picture is of them together in the bows of Clari and was stolen from Opera Fresh.  Congratulations, my dears.

PS. Please note validation here and here.

Monday, June 21, 2010

14

I am happy with this list only if there are 14 names.

 
Renée Fleming


 
Natalie Dessay


 
Anna Netrebko


 
Angela Gheorghiu


 
Elina Garanča


 
Cecilia Bartoli


 
Joyce DiDonato


 
Juan Diego Florez


 
Jonas Kaufmann


 
Placido Domingo


 
Simon Keenlyside


 
René Pape


 
Bryn Terfel


 
Dmitri Hvorostovsky


And yes, this is this year's sexiest list. I have tried to use pictures I've never used before. Surprise. In this set of pictures the sexiest by far is Placido Domingo.

Thursday, December 10, 2009

The rise of Jonas Kaufmann


I feel proud to have witnessed the rise of the career of Jonas Kaufmann. When I first began writing about him there were only about 3 videos of him on YouTube. Now there are over 600 without duplicates.

On 1/23/2007, almost three years ago, I wandered quite by accident into a performance of Fidelio at the Zurich opera. I described him as "a Florestan to die for." I was going for the opera rather than the performers. I immediately pegged him as a Heldentenor. And here.

By March he had made my sexiest list. A year later I was calling him "my boy."

Well, I guess he isn't mine any more. Everyone is flying to Milan to hear him in Carmen. They love him all around the world. Congratulations, Jonas. You deserve it.

The woman in the picture is his wife.

P.S. I feel I must add a footnote. I knew Jonas existed long before this because I saw him in Nina, La Pazza per Amore, the Paisiello opera filmed in Zurich with Cecilia Bartoli. What changed in the Fidelio performance was the idea that he might be significant for something besides his looks.

Thursday, July 30, 2009

Maria Ewing

I cannot explain my taste for this "picture" of Maria Ewing, found by accident on the internet. There's a whole website full of these here. I think the part above the forehead is not so pointy, but the picture is clearly her.

Maria is the only opera singer included in this set. I am assuming that if you wanted to do 3d animation, you could choose these heads as the faces for your characters, attach them to suitable stock bodies, add hair and outfits, and off you go.


Here's something a little more conventional.





Maria is an artist who specialized in very theatrical opera, may be regarded as a founder of the genre. She was most famous for two roles, both entirely outside her natural lyric soprano Fach: Carmen and Salome. She allowed nothing to stand in her way, even nudity.